|
Over
the last three years, Romania has seen a substantial change in
the way its health-care sector is financed, namely, a shift towards
the funding of health-care by means of an insurance system. The
introduction of health insurance increased the amount of public
funding available for that sector. Yet despite this positive development
in terms of revenue, at least half the users of the health services
report making additional out-of-pocket payments. Moreover, although
the budget has benefited from a surplus of revenue from the health
sector, the quality of service is increasingly viewed as inadequate,
and the system's performance is poor in terms of equal access.
Public funding for health-care, a trend that compares favorably
to other social services, should be interpreted against a history
of tight control on sector expenditure and inputs until 1998.
At 3.8% of GDP (1999), public expenditure on health in Romania
remains among the lowest in the ECA region: the only countries
with a lower share are those where tax collection has virtually
collapsed.
Resolving the imbalance created by the improvement in the funding
of health-care following recent reforms, and the inefficient use
of resources – as indicated by the persistent low marks
for services and the anecdotal evidence of large, private out-of-pocket
payments – is becoming an increasingly important part of
reforming social service provision more generally. If the health
sector can be made to respond to health-care needs more effectively
and equitably after the introduction of an insurance system designed
to enhance revenue performance, then lessons may emerge for other
parts of the social service delivery systems. If, on the other
hand, the rationalization of the financing side corresponds to
a continued deterioration, and not to improvements, in the allocation
of spending, the main benefits of the reform are in doubt.
The state budget was the only public source of health-care funding
until 1991. The Ministry of Health, as well as other ministries
with their own health service provider networks (e.g., Defense,
Interior, and Transport) administered these funds. In the early
1990s the move towards diversifying the sources of funding gained
support within Romania as a way of spreading the burden of allocating
resources for the health sector. As part of this trend, the Government
introduced partial reimbursement of prescription drugs for outpatient
care in 1992. The move was accompanied by the establishment of
the Special Health Fund, also administered by the Ministry of
Health and Family and based mainly on a two percent payroll tax,
but also including revenues from small taxes on tobacco and alcohol
sales, and advertising. In 1993, responsibility for funding material
expenditure other than for drugs, as well as utilities and current
maintenance, was transferred from the state to local budgets.
The adoption of the Law on Social Health Insurance in 1997 initiated
the transformation of the Romanian health-care system from a Semashko
state-financed model to an insurance-based system. Since the law
came into force in 1998, earmarked payroll contributions have
become the main source of health sector revenue. Key provisions
of the law regulate health sector revenue generation and redistribution,
as well as the allocation of funds. The 1997 law made insurance
membership mandatory and linked it with employment. Contributions
depend on income and are paid in even shares by the insured and
the employer. Children and young people, disabled persons, and
war veterans as well as dependents without income have free access
to health insurance. For conscripted soldiers and people serving
prison sentences, insurance contributions are paid from the budgets
of the Ministry of Defense and Ministry of Justice.
Health insurance covers ambulatory, inpatient, and dental care,
including clinical preventive services and drugs. A framework
contract, agreed upon annually by the National Health Insurance
Fund (NHIF) and the College of Physicians and approved by the
Cabinet, defines the benefits package, conditions for service
delivery, and payment mechanisms. Co-payments are required for
drugs and allowed for other services. Family physicians play a
gatekeeper role.
The framework contract sets the terms for health-care services
using a variety of parameters. This contract is the basis of the
contracts between the District Health Insurance Funds (DHIFs)
and health-care providers (hospital and their outpatient units,
diagnosis and treatment centers, health centers, basic clinics,
and medical offices).
The most important features of the health insurance contract are
as follows:
- Insurance
benefits include medical services from the first day of sickness
or the date of accident until the patient is fully recovered.
- Medical
services include preventive health-care services, ambulatory
health-care, hospital care, dentistry services, medical emergency
services, complementary medical rehabilitation services, pre-,
intra-and post-birth medical assistance, home-care nursing,
drugs, health-care materials, and orthopedic devices.
- The
insured are entitled to choose a family doctor for primary health-care
services and, once referred by the family doctor, can have the
choice of a specialist ambulatory care provider. Inpatient care
includes full or partial hospitalization with medical examination
and investigations, diagnosis, medical and/or surgical treatment,
nursing, drugs, and health-care supplies, accommodation, and
food.
- Health
insurance covers 40 to 60 percent of the cost of dental care,
taking into account previous use of prophylactic dental check-ups.
In accordance with the framework insurance contract, these treatments
are fully covered for children aged less than 16.
- The
Ministry of Health and Family and the NHIF, using recommendations
from the College of Physicians and the College of Pharmacists,
compile a list of prescription drugs on a yearly basis with
reference prices. Pharmacists must sell the cheapest available
drug, if only the generic name is on the prescription, and must
mention potential substitutes.
- The
insured are entitled to prescription drugs; health-care materials
needed to correct eyesight and hearing, and prostheses of the
limbs are also either partially reimbursed by the insurance
funds or free.
- Coverage
of medical rehabilitation, home-care and transportation related
to medical treatment and housekeeping support during illness
or disability are also regulated by the framework insurance
contract.
Health insurance does not cover professional risks and diseases,
certain high-tech health-care services, various dentistry services,
curative health-care assistance in the workplace, and luxury accommodation
services in hospital, all of which must be paid for directly by
the patients or from other sources (employer, professional risk
insurance, and private insurance).
Health expenditure from public sources in Romania between 1990-1999
varied between 2.8 and 3.8 percent of GDP, equivalent to $28-58
per capita.
Out-of-pocket Payments
Based on data from the Integrated Household Survey of the National
Commission for Statistics, private spending on health-care in
1996 was estimated at 1,306 billion Lei ($432 million) or about
29 percent of total health expenditures.
An important part of this sum goes directly or indirectly to public
providers or their staff through charges for services and/or under-the-table
payments (illegal payments to providers for services that are
nominally free). This level of out-of-pocket payments is higher
than the average level of private expenditure in the OECD countries,
but lower than in countries such as Australia and the United States.
Compared to other ECA countries, Romania seems to be in the middle
group where out-of-pocket payments and the frequency or level
of informal payments are concerned.
Health care delivery system
The Ministry of Health is the central authority in public health,
responsible for setting organization and functioning standards
for public health institutions, developing and financing national
public health programs, data collection, empowering public health
officials and drawing up reports on the population's health status.
The Institute for Maternal and Child Care (IMCC) advises the Ministry
on standards for maternal and child health and takes part in health
programs. As well as compiling epidemiological data and setting
standards, it is involved in the National Program of Family Planning,
in training obstetricians, and in supervising midwifery training.
The National Advisory Board for Epidemiology and the National
Advisory Board for Health Care Management and Public Health are
created within the Ministry of Health.
Their advice is taken when the Ministry of Health is faced with
specific topics of strategic importance for setting public health
issues.
Family planning
Family Planning and Sexual Education unit has been set up within
the Department for Maternal and Child Health of the Ministry of
Health. Since 1992, eleven reference centers for reproductive
health have been established. Nine of these centers are based
in university clinics and two are at district level. They provide
information and technical assistance, family planning, abortion,
and cancer-screening services. They also train staff for other
centers: since July 1995, it has been possible to grant accreditation
in family planning. The project was assisted by WHO, UNFPA and
the Department of Continuing Education of the Ministry of Health,
and it was funded by the World Bank Project. A parallel network
for family planning has also been created through various nongovernmental
organizations. Permanent contraceptive methods are not yet promoted
as there is no law permitting voluntary sterilization. Previous
legislation, which only allowed sterilization for medical reasons,
for mothers of five or more children, or for women over 45 years
old, is as yet unchanged.
Primary health care
Until 1999, primary health care was mainly performed through a
countrywide network of about 6000 dispensaries. The dispensaries
belonged to the Ministry of Health and Family and were administered
through the local hospital which also held territorial funds for
both primary and secondary health care. Community-based clinics
provided health care for children under the age of five, housewives,
pensioners and the unemployed living within a specific area. There
were also enterprise-based clinics for employees (sometimes for
a number of adjacent enterprises) and school clinics providing
medical care for anyone in full-time education. Patients were
not allowed to choose their dispensary, but were assigned one
according to their place of employment or residence. Starting
from 1998, patients were allowed to choose their basic clinic,
i.e. their family doctor. The Health Insurance Law stipulates
that a family doctor may be changed after a minimum of three months
after initial registration with that doctor.
According to new legislation related to the implementation of
the health insurance system, general practitioners moved from
being state employees to independent practitioners, contracted
by the (public) health insurance funds, but operating their medical
offices privately.
Since 1990, there have also been private medical offices staffed
by general practitioners or specialists. The physicians who work
in these generally divide their time between the public and private
sectors.
Access to outpatient clinic and hospital specialty services now
officially requires a referral by the family practitioner, but
since 1989, the referral system has increasingly been bypassed
and the frequency of primary health care consultation has declined.
Ambulatory secondary care
Ambulatory secondary health care is delivered by the network of
hospital outpatients departments, centers for diagnosis and treatment
and office-based specialists.
Physicians working in private medical offices need a free practice
license and an authorization for the medical unit. Private outpatient
services may be accredited for all specialties including outpatient
surgery.
Inpatient care
There are four main categories of hospitals in Romania:
- Rural
hospitals, which have a minimum of 120 beds and provide internal
medicine and pediatric services.
- Town
and municipal hospitals, with at least 250 and 400 beds, respectively,
and departments of internal medicine, surgery, gynecology-obstetrics
and pediatrics.
- District
hospitals in larger have, in addition, departments for orthopedics,
intensive care, ophthalmology and otorhinolaryngology.
- Specialized
units for tertiary care such as the Institute for Mather and
Child, the Institute of Oncology, The Neurosurgery Hospital,
the Institute of Balneophysiotherapy and Recovery, the Institute
of Pneumophysiology and a number of cardiovascular and other
surgery departments in teaching hospitals.
In terms of ownership, except for few small hospitals, all hospitals
are publicly owned and are under state administration. They are
led by a council board and a general director who holds executive
power. This appointment is made by the relevant district public
health directorate and is usually held by a physician. There are
two deputy directors, a physician and an economist. The council
board is appointed by the general director and usually includes
representatives of the different departments within the hospital:
health care, nursing, pharmacy, administration and accounts.
Social care
There is not yet a proper community-based social care network
in Romania, but a number of organizations may be considered as
starting points in its development. The ministries involved in
social care are the Ministry of Health, the Ministry of Labor
and Social Solidarity, the Ministry of Education and Research,
Department for Child Protection, and the State Secretariat for
Handicapped People.
According to different research, as many as 40% of patient days
in Romania's acute-care hospitals are devoted to social cases.
These are patients with minor medical problems who cannot be discharged
because suitable alternatives are not readily available. Long-term
and convalescent care facilities, hospice units for cancer and
AIDS patients, home care, and other community care programs are
still underdeveloped. As the health reform program is implemented,
hospitals will be under increasing pressure to discharge these
patients. The health insurance funds, for example, while authorized
to purchase community care services, are under no obligation to
pay for care provided inappropriately in facilities or to create
or finance alternative community care.
The most recent Ministry of Health data indicate that Romania
has one practicing physician for every 580 people, or 17.7 per
10.000 people.
Key contacts:
William H. Crawford, Senior Commercial Officer
Dublin, Ireland
Tel. 353-1-667-4752; Fax 353-1-667-4754
E-mail: Bill.Crawford@mail.doc.gov
or
Doina Brancusi, Commercial Assistant
American Embassy, Bucharest
Tel. (40-1) 210-40-42; Fax (40-1) 210-40-42
E-mail: brancusi@usembassy.ro;
doina.brancusi@mail.doc.gov
Source:
US Dept. of Commerce
Demographics & Economic Situation
Source: Factbook.net
|